The Don Layfield Trophy was originally awarded to the highest marked club umpire. From 2016 club umpires were not marked and it was awarded to long standing club umpires. Since 2023 it has been awarded to the runner-up to the Lance Moore Trophy winner. 

 

2022 John Oswald Harrogate/Knaresborough 

2021 Trevor Markham Hull Zingari 

2020 Not awarded; Covid-19 affected season 

2019 Keith Houlston Sessay 

2018 Phil Robshaw Thirsk 

2017 Eric Wade Stillington 

2016 David Lockwood New Earswick 

2015 Chris Harrison Sheriff Hutton Bridge 

2014 Peter Nolton Woodhouse Grange 

2013 David Turpin Rowntrees & Huntington 

2012 Colin Mole Sheriff Hutton Bridge 

2011 Colin Mole Sheriff Hutton Bridge 

2010 Colin Mole Sheriff Hutton Bridge 

2009 Darren Atkinson Malton & Old Malton 

2008 Peter Nolton Woodhouse Grange